3DNews Vendor Reference English Resource -
All you need to know about your products!
Biostar And ECS CPU Boundedness Foxconn 9800GTX
About Us | Advertise  
Digital-Daily.com
Digital-Daily

Motherboard
CPU & Memory
Video
Mobile
Cooling
Editorial
Digital
Links

Google
Web
www.digital-daily.com
www.3dnews.ru








Digital-Daily : Motherboard Reviews : msi_intel_amd

MSI G33M and K9NGM3: new MoBos on integrated chipsets

MSI G33M and K9NGM3: new MoBos on integrated chipsets
Author: Aleksandr Mitrofanov
Date: 22.10.2007

Performance

While determining the starting FSB/HTT speed, it turned out that MSI G33M overstates it by merely 1 MHz, whereas MSI K9NGM3 downstates it equally.

In our test setup, we used the following hardware:


Test setup
CPU Intel Core 2 Duo E6700 LGA775 (2.66 GHz; Conroe)
AMD Athlon 64 3500+ (real clock speed 2.2 GHz)
AMD Athlon X2 6000+ (real clock speed 3.0 GHz)
Cooler Gigabyte 3D Cooler GP Edition
Video Card Integrated graphic core Intel GMA X3100
NVIDIA GeForce FX 5750; PCI Express x16
Driver version: 91.31
Integrated graphic core NVIDIA GeForce 7050
Sound card -
HDD Samsung HD160JJ
Memory 2x512 MB Corsair DDR2 TWIN2X1024-8000UL1
Housing Inwin506 with PowerMan 300 W PSU
OS Windows XP SP1

Let's first take a look at the results of synthetic benchmarks. But we should note first that Gigabyte 965G-DS3 and MSI G965M are based on Intel G965. MSI G965M uses the slowest PCI-E video card, namely, GeForce FX 5750. Therefore, we'll be comparing the performance of systems with the integrated and discrete graphics. Another interesting comparison is in the difference of operating speed of MSI K9NGM3 with the single-core Athlon 64 3500+ and DDR2-800 memory, and the same board with the dual-core Athlon X2 6000+ plus DDR2-667 memory of the same capacity. And despite the impressive difference in speed, there is absolutely no difference at speed!

Now on to the gaming benchmarks.

Another test - WinRar (Kb/s.; the more, the better)

Conclusions regarding the performance in 3D applications. Of course, the operating speed of the integrated graphic is twice as slow versus the weakest PCI Express video card, however, we should note a performance gain of the former. First, the chipset G33 with Intel's latest drivers is well ahead of its predecessor (that is, G965). But in combination with a CPU of the Core 2 Duo architecture it is well ahead of the integrated AMD platform.

However, the GeForce 7050 chipset is functionally superior to any Intel's graphic solutions and supports all 3D applications which we have just tried. But the Intel chipset has a number of incompatibilities: the outdated Comanche does not work (Intel Gxxx does not support T&L ), nor works GunMetal (problems with drivers), and at X2-Threat the Intel chipset won due to the worse and more simplified details in the 3D image. Moreover, the functional superiority NVIDIA's graphic core provides a high speed in modern 3D games like Doom 3, Far Cry, and Half Life 2. In particular, at Doom 3 and Far Cry the operating speed of GeForce 7050 is much higher, and in Half Life 2 - absolutely the same but attained with a very weak processor (Athlon 64 3500+).

Final Words

In choosing a value integrated motherboard, we should keep two important factors in mind: the 2D quality, and the retail price. At the quality of the image, there is nothing to complain about any of these boards, and at the price - the MSI board based on GeForce 7050 costs $30 less. At the same time, the expansion options, package bundle, and the functionality of both the boards are approximately equal. So the conclusion is simple: of the two tested motherboards, MSI K9NGM3 looks more attractive. And we recommend to use it in combination with a cheap single-core CPU and DDR2-800 memory.

Of special mention is the good overclocking capability. At that, the superiority is with MSI G33M which showed simply fantastic results (FSB = 474 MHz). In other words, this board is an excellent buy for overclocking for both value Intel CPU of 800 MHz bus and CPUs of middle level of 1066 MHz bus.

Conclusion

MSI G33M
MSI K9NGM3
Pros:
  • high stability and good performance level;
  • graphic core Intel GMA X3100 and one PCI Express x16 slot;
  • support for SerialATA II ( 5 links; ICH9 + Marvell 88SE6111);
  • support for one P-ATA line (Marvell 88SE6111);
  • integrated 8-channel audio and Gigabit Ethernet LAN controller;
  • support for USB2.0 (12 ports) and IEEE-1394 (Firewire; 2 ports).
Cons:
  • Not found.
The board's specific features:
  • well developed overclocking tools (plus excellent results).
Pros:
  • high stability and good performance level;
  • graphic core GeForce 7050 and one PCI Express x16 slot;
  • support for SerialATA II (4 lines; nForce 630i);
  • support for one P-ATA link (nForce 630i);
  • integrated 8-channel audio and Gigabit Ethernet LAN controller;
  • support for the USB 2.0 (10 ports);
  • affordable price.
Cons:
  • Not found.
The board's specific features:
  • well developed overclocking tools (plus good results).


- Discuss the material in a conference

Content:

  • Page 1 - Specifications, package bundle
  • Page 2 - Layout and Features; Expansion options
  • Page 3 - BIOS, monitoring, overclocking tools
  • Page 4 - Overclocking and stability
  • Page 5 - Performance and conclusions




  • Top Stories:
    MoBo:


    XFX GTX 280 XXX and MSI HD 4870: not only overclocking
    Jetway HA03 Ultra (AMD 790X)
    ECS GF8200A (NVIDIA GeForce 8200) with integrated graphics
    MSI P45 Platinum and ASUS P5Q Deluxe (Intel P45)
    ECS P45T-A (Intel P45)
    Foxconn A78AX-S and abit AX78 - value motherboards on the AMD 770 chipset
    Foxconn A7GM-S (AMD 780G) + tests of the Hybrid CrossFire
    VGA Card:


    Radeon HD4870 CrossFire vs. GeForce GTX 280: quantity vs. quality
    ASUS EAH3850 X2: a metal-framed exclusive
    Radeon HD4870 - a new king in the top-middle class
    NVIDIA GeForce GTX 280 – fast and hot
    Gainward BLISS 9600GSO 768 Mb: does much video memory make much sense?
    Tests of flagship video cards in 1680x1050, 1920x1200, and 2048x1536
    ASUS HD4850 - first tests of the latest GPU AMD RV770
    CPU & Memory:

    CPU Intel Atom 230 (Diamondville)
    Chaintech Apogee GT DDR3 1600
    CPU Intel E7200 (Wolfdale)
    Memory (RAM): spring 2008
    Memory (RAM): early 2008
    AMD Spider: Phenom processors, 7-Series chipsets, etc.
    Intel QX9650 (Penryn): first tests


      Management by AK
      Design VisualPharm.com

    Copyright © 2002-2008 3DNews.Ru All Rights Reserved.
    contact - info@digital-daily.com
    Digital-Daily - English-language version of the popular Russian web-project 3DNews